Laboratory 14
Evolution Assignment
 

Pamela J. W. Gore

Department of Geology, Georgia Perimeter College

Clarkston, GA 30021

Copyright ã 1997, 1999, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005 Pamela J. W. Gore


This assignment will allow you to explore some interesting aspects of evolution.

You may do this assignment in class if computers are available, or your instructor may assign it as homework. The questions are to be answered by accessing the internet. Type your answers using a word processor.

1 THE BASICS OF EVOLUTION

Use the hyperlinked references below to answer the following questions. Your answers to the questions in this lab should be one or two well written paragraphs, or one or two pages for each question to discuss the topic adequately.

Do NOT answer these questions with a copy and paste technique on the computer. That is plagiarism. Instead, read each reference thoroughly and put the material into your own words.

  1. What is the modern synthesis?

  2. What is macroevolution? Explain.

  3. Punctuated equilibrium.
    1. What is punctuated equilibrium?
    2. What evidence supports punctuated equilibrium?
    3. What are some possible explanations for rapid evolutionary changes?

  4. What is allopatric speciation? (Look under "Modes of Speciation".)

  5. What are five lines of evidence in support of the theory of evolution? (Also, see your lecture notes.)

  6. Are there examples of observed speciation? (See this reference also.) List and explain.

  7. What are some of the vertebrate transition fossils? List and discuss specific examples. (See this reference also.) Discuss examples of various genera that are transitional between each of the major groups of vertebrates. You do not need to define the term "vertebrate transition fossils" in your answer.

  8. Did humans evolve from monkeys? Explain. (See this reference also.)

The hyperlinks below each explore different aspects of evolution that you need to be familiar with for this course. Please visit all of the web sites listed, keeping in mind the questions you will need to answer for this lab.

Readings:

  1. Evolution and the Fossil Record, booklet online, published by American Geological Institute and the Paleontological Society
  2. National Association of Biology Teachers position statement on teaching evolution
  3. PBS Evolution TV series web site
  4. Evolution vs.Creation Science (Ontario Centre for Religious Tolerance) - (http://www.religioustolerance.org/evolutio.htm).
  5. University of California, Berkeley - (http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/history/evolution.html)
  6. Harvard Dept of Molecular and Cellular Biology Biology Links: Evolution
  7. Evolution - Talk-Origins Archive - (http://www.talkorigins.org/origins/faqs-evolution.html)
  8. Frequently asked questions on evolution from Talk-Origins Archive - (http://www.talkorigins.org/origins/faqs.html)
  9. Observed instances of speciation
  10. Vertebrate Transition Fossils
  11. National Academy of Science Publication, "Teaching About Evolution and the Nature of Science" - (http://www.nap.edu/readingroom/books/evolution98/)
  12. Introduction to Evolutionary Biology - (http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-intro-to-biology.html)
  13. God and Evolution - (http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-god.html)
  14. Evolution is a Fact and a Theory - (http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/evolution-fact.html)
  15. Problems with a global flood - (http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-noahs-ark.html)
  16. National Center for Science Education
  17. Tree of Life website

You are required to know about the evidence in support of evolution. The diversity of opinions you encounter will be stimulating and exciting. Keep an open mind. Look for well documented evidence (photos? maps?), work done by trained professionals (name, place of employment, dates listed), etc.

2
WHALE ORIGINS

In the early Cenozoic, mammals diverged rapidly from rodent-like ancestors to forms as diverse as whales (swimming mammals)and bats (flying mammals). This is called an adaptive radiation.

This assignment asks you to research and learn about the origin of whales as revealed by the fossil record.

Answer the following questions.

  1. What is the significance of Basilosaurus? Describe the significant feature of its skeletal structure.
  2. Where have Basilosaurus fossils been found?
  3. In what epoch did Basilosaurus live?
  4. The oldest group of fossil whales, the archaeocetes, (such as Pakicetus) have whale-like features as well as features of land dwelling mammals. What are these features?
  5. In what epoch did Pakicetus live?
  6. What are mesonychians?
  7. Whales may be related to what modern mammal?
  8. The transition from the land to the sea affected the hearing system in addition to the locomotor system. Describe the hearing system in whales, as compared with that of land-dwelling mammals.
  9. What is osmoregulation, and how does it relate to whales making the transition to the sea?

Readings:

3
UNUSUAL EVOLUTIONARY IDEAS
Aquatic Ape Theory (Hypothesis, really) - Science or Pseudoscience?

You will find the Aquatic Ape Theory (more correctly called a hypothesis) interesting. Can you tell why it is not considered to be a valid theory?

The Aquatic Ape Theory makes the argument that humans have many features in common with marine mammals. While there is a very compelling list of similarities, there is LITTLE OR NO HARD EVIDENCE to support the theory. Read about it and see what you think. This theory is not generally regarded seriously, but you will be amazed at the list of features we have in common with marine mammals. What does it all mean? (And is it all true?)

Aquatic Ape Information

  1. Leaflet printed by Accent of Swansea for Elaine Morgan - with pictures - (http://www.geocities.com/Athens/5168/aat/leaflet.html)
  2. AAT Pages - (http://www.geocities.com/Athens/5168/aat.html)

Critiques of the Aquatic Ape hypothesis

"There are very good reasons why this theory is dismissed by almost all biologists. It's a classic example of why a little knowledge about evolution can be a very dangerous thing. "
  1. Adventures in Pseudoscience: The Aquatic Ape Theory - http://imprint.uwaterloo.ca/issues/100496/4Science/science03.html
  2. Wikipedia - http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aquatic_ape_hypothesis
  3. Did humans descend from "aquatic apes"? - - http://www.straightdope.com/mailbag/maquaticape.html
  4. Aquatic Ape Theory - Sink or Swim. A scientific critique by Jim Moore - http://www.aquaticape.org/
Other references
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/5168/aat/refs.html.

Your assignment is to write an essay on why the aquatic ape hypothesis is dismissed as pseudoscience.

If you liked this, see the Pliocene Pussy Cat Theory. Alternate sites (1), (2).

4
SEARCHING FOR INFORMATION ON THE WEB

Take this opportunity to use several web-based search-engines to research evolution. Start with the following:

  1. Google (http://www.google.com).
  2. Yahoo - (http://www.yahoo.com) . This search engine provides a clickable list of topics that you may find to be of general interest to you. To locate the evolution references, look under Science - Click on Biology - and then on Evolution. Scroll on down and see a listing of general evolution sites.
  3. or your favorite search engine.

You can type in "evolution" or "science biology evolution" or "science geology evolution" or "evolution fossils geology" or some other combinations. There are a lot of references on evolution. Try to see a diversity of viewpoints.

Write a 3-paged typed double spaced paper, with a font size of 10 or 12 and a 1-inch margin all the way around. Write about what you learned. You may add a brief opinion at the end, but the main purpose of the paper is to document the NEW ideas you encounter and the evidence for them.

Please use web resources, and cite them correctly, following one of the following guides.

Include URLs (web page reference locations) so that you or your instructor can go back to the sources.
Also, print out any pages that you cite so that your instructor can see the original source.

Let your instructor know if you have any problems.


Return to Contents


This page created by Pamela J. W. Gore
Georgia Perimeter College

Modified July 15, 1999
Modified June 7, 2001
Modified January 31, 2002
Web links updated March 20, 2003
Updated October 10, 2003
Modified December 13, 2003
Modified April 6, 2004
Web link updated December 10, 2004